Bootlin at the Linux Media Summit 2018

This year’s edition of the Linux Media Summit happened a month ago, in Edinburgh, right after the Embedded Linux Conference. Since we were already at the ELCE, and that we’ve been more and more involved in the media community thanks to our work on the Allwinner CSI driver and more importantly the Cedrus driver, it was natural for us to attend.

The media summit is usually a meeting to discuss the hot topics, so the whole day was a mix and match of various status updates and discussions on the future needs and developments around the Video4Linux2 framework.

Linux Media Summit attendees

Most of the discussion was about how to improve the contributor’s experience and improve the maintenance. The DRM subsystem was used as an example, since the number of patches are in the same order of magnitude, and a number of v4l2 contributors are also contributing to DRM drivers. Part of the improvement of both the maintenance and contribution experience will also come through some CI work, so there was a lot of discussions on how to improve the already existing tools (such as v4l2-compliance) but also how to setup some automatic tooling to run those tests as early as possible.

A good part of the day was also spent on dealing with the current developments, such as the Request API we’ve used in the Cedrus driver, and how to integrate that API into popular multimedia frameworks like gstreamer or ffmpeg. It looks like our libva implementation was well received, so it will probably be made standard and hosted on linuxtv.org in the near future. Other developments discussed were fault tolerant v4l2, in order to deal with video pipelines where one or several components might not work anymore, and storing the v4l2 controls state in a persistent way.

It was overall a very productive day, and it’s always nice to meet people you interact with over mailing list and IRC on a regular basis. If you want more information, you can read the extensive report.

Bootlin at the XDC 2018 Conference

This year’s edition of the X.org Developpers Conference (XDC) happened two weeks ago in A Coruña, Spain. While its name suggests that it might be focused solely on the X.org display server, this conference is actually targeted at the whole Linux graphics stack, including alternative stacks like Android’s or Wayland servers. Following our involvment in the Linux DRM subsystem, and to deepen our understanding and involvement in the graphics stack, Bootlin sent one engineer, Maxime Ripard, maintainer of the sun4i DRM driver.

There’s been a lot of interesting talks during those three days, as you can see in the conference schedule, but we especially liked a few of those:

Jens Owens, Pierre-Loup Griffais – Open Source Driver Development Funding Hooking up the Money Hose – Slides

The opening talk was made by Jens Owens, from Google, and Pierre-Loup Griffais, from Valve. They provided some interesting feedback and insights from two companies with a quite central position in the gaming industry. They also advocated for open source drivers, and the way they were actually helping the game developpers.

Haneen Mohamed, Rodrigo Siqueira: VKMS – Slides

Haneen Mohamed and Rodrigo Siqueira were on stage to talk about their work as part of the Google Summer of Code and Outreachy programs to work on a Virtual KMS driver. This driver is still in its early stage, but got merged and while basic at the moment, holds a lot of promises to use it as a KMS backend for testing the KMS API.

Jerome Glisse – getting rid of get_user_page() in favor of HMM – Slides

Jerome Glisse, from Red Hat, came to describe his current work on the memory management subsystem of the Linux kernel. He’s working on dealing with the constraints that the systems using GPUs to offload computations have when it comes to allocating memory in the most efficient way.

Overall, this was a great description about the get_user_page interface pitfalls when used in that context, and from the work that he has been doing for the past years to overcome them.

Lyude Paul, Alyssa Rosenzweig – Introducing Panfrost – Slides

In that talk, Lyude Paul and Alyssa Rosenzweig were showing the work they did on Panfrost, the reverse-engineering effort around the Mali-T GPUs from ARM (which was then expanded to the Mali-G GPUs). They discussed the result of their findings, explained the architecture of the GPU and then talked about the current state of their work. The final part of the talk was a quick demo of their work on a Rockchip SoC. It provided a great overview of the current state of the driver, and there’s a lot of hope for an open-source driver for that GPU that is quite widely used on ARM.

Elie Tournier – What’s new in the virtual world? – Slides

Elie Tournier, from Collabora, gave a talk about his work and the current state of virgl, which is a virtual 3D GPU meant to be used within qemu virtual machines, while remaining independant of the host GPU. While we were aware of the existence of that driver for quite some time, this talk provided a great overview of the features that are provided by virgl, and what you can and cannot do with it.

Conclusion

After XDC in 2016 in Helsinki, this was our second time attending that conference. Just like the first time, we really enjoyed the single track format where you can meet all the attendees and have side discussions pretty easily. Once again, the talks were great, and lead us to think about interesting developments we could do on our various projects.

More OpenGL binaries for the Mali support on Allwinner platforms with mainline Linux

Allwinner SoCBack in September, we announced the availability of Mali userspace blobs that provide OpenGL acceleration on Allwinner platforms using the mainline Linux kernel. Back then, only the r6p2 version of the Mali blobs were available, with only the x11 and fbdev backends, and only for ARM 32 bits. Following the announcement we made last September, we kept talking with Allwinner to release more binaries and increase the usefulness of them. Two major categories were missing in order to complete the previous batch of binaries Allwinner allowed us to distribute: Wayland and arm64 flavours.

After some discussions, Allwinner provided to us this week additional Mali blobs, covering Wayland support, ARM64, and also newer versions for some of them. Overall, we now provide:

  • r6p2 version, ARM 32 bits, X11
  • r6p2 version, ARM 32 bits, fbdev
  • r6p2 version, ARM 32 bits, Wayland (new)
  • r6p2 version, ARM 64 bits, X11 (new)
  • r6p2 version, ARM 64 bits, fbdev (new)
  • r6p2 version, ARM 64 bits, Wayland (new)
  • r8p1 version, ARM 32 bits, fbdev (new)
  • r8p1 version, ARM 64 bits, fbdev (new)

We pushed everything to our github repo, enjoy! See our previous blog post for instructions on how to use those blobs.

Those binary blobs are useful because they allow today to have a fully working OpenGL acceleration on Allwinner platforms: we recently ran a Qt5 application doing OpenGL rendering 24/7 on an Allwinner A33 platform for 1.5 month uninterrupted, as a stability test. Of course, long term, we are following the progress of the Lima project, which will provide a completely free and open-source solution to provide OpenGL acceleration on Allwinner platforms.

Testing pixel formats on the RaspberryPi

As part of our ongoing work with the RaspberryPi Foundation, we’ve been working on a number of display-related topics recently. Besides the work done by my colleague Boris Brezillon on improving the kernel side support for a number of features (such as the GPU performance counters support, memory management improvements, etc.), I’ve been working on improving the CI infrastructure for display driver testing.

Indeed, the current workflow is not automated at all and doesn’t allow to detect breakages in the display driver. We thus needed to improve that. To do so, we’ve relied on a board developed by Google as part of the ongoing CI-effort on ChromeOS that is called the Chamelium. The Chamelium is based on an ARM board powered by an Altera SoC+FPGA platform that Google extended with an extension board with video connectivity: VGA, HDMI and DisplayPort. They then developed a firmware for the FPGA to allow the board to emulate a screen.

A RaspberryPi and the Chamelium

Using this, you can simulate improper EDIDs, simulate hotplug events, HDCP screens, etc. and see how the device under test reacts to that. One of the interesting things you can do with it is to dump a CRC of the frame received on the display link, or a raw capture of a given number of frames. The usefulness of such a feature is obvious for a CI effort: you connect the device to test over HDMI, VGA or DP to the Chamelium, and then you can setup a test pattern on the device you want to test, capture the frame received on the other end, and compare the two frames. In an ideal scenario, the two are identical, and if your driver has a regression, you’ll notice as the two frames would no longer be identical.

The intel-gpu-tools suite (also called i-g-t), even though historically named with a not-so-generic name, is a standard test suite for the DRM subsystem in Linux. Last summer, the support for the Chamelium has been introduced for exactly this setup, where intel-gpu-tools would setup a test pattern, ask the Chamelium for a CRC of the frames it received and do the comparison.

This was working fine, and after a quick test on the RaspberryPi, it turned out to work on non-Intel hardware out of the box. However, the test was actually quite simple: while it was testing all the resolutions exposed, it was only testing a single pixel format, and we wanted to do more in order to catch regressions in less common formats, and ideally the RaspberryPi proprietary formats as well.

When it comes to pixel formats, there are two main families involved:

  • the RGB formats, sometimes prefixed with an A (for alpha, the opacity) or X (for padding), and the YCbCr family (also called abusively YUV). The former will have different values for each primary color, encoded on a number of bits following the RGB prefix. XRGB1555 for example will be a 16 bits format (1 + 5 + 5 + 5), with 1 bit of padding, and 5 bits for red, green and blue in that order.
  • the YCbCr formats, based on the property of the human eye that it perceives better the changes in luminosity than in color and will thus store the luminance (Y) and chrominance (Cb and Cr) in separate fields, with possibly a different number of bits. While RGB is usually preferred by computer graphics, video is very fond of the YCbCr formats since you can compress the Cb and Cr fields, resulting in a denser pixel format, without degrading the image quality too much.

The format initially supported by intel-gpu-tools was the XRGB8888 (8 bits of padding, 8 bits for red, green and blue, in that order). The RaspberryPi supports the RGB formats XRGB8888, ARGB8888, ABGR8888, XBGR8888, RGB565, BGR565, ARGB1555, XRGB1555, RGB888, BGR888.

Like we said, i-g-t was on the contrary using only an XRGB8888 format for the test pattern. This unfortunately was based on a few assumptions, the first one being that the test pattern would be generated with Cairo. However, Cairo supports a very limited range of formats. On the formats supported on the RaspberryPi, Cairo only supported ARGB8888, XRGB8888 and RGB565. This was obviously not enough, but we didn’t really want to extend Cairo since our goal was to be able to run the test suite on as many devices as possible. One option would have been to update the version of Cairo in use to support a larger number of formats, but that was not considered to be the most appropriate solution. We thus evaluated our options, and it turned out pixman supports most of the RGB formats, and it was already a dependency of intel-gpu-tools.

So in a patch series that we submitted recently to the intel-gpu-tools project, we:

  • create an API to allow the core i-g-t functions that handle the buffers to let us simply map the underlying DRM buffer in order to access it, without having to use Cairo and its limited pixel format support
  • rework the code a bit to be able to use Cairo when relevant, and then fallback to Pixman if the format isn’t supported. Pixman list of formats supported isn’t ideal either, especially in the YCbCr family, but we focused on RGB first. In order to allow for additional fallbacks, we hid it behind an API so that it’s transparent to the users
  • create a custom pattern solely for the Chamelium test, which was needed to deal with the difference of sampling size for each color component
  • glue those functions into the Chamelium test suite and add one sub-test for each format, so that we can detect both regressions in handling the format itself, but also regressions in the list of formats exposed
  • add a VC4 test suite, extended with Chamelium based tests

All this work has then be submitted to the intel-gpu-tools mailing list for review, and while the development was done on a RaspberryPi, it should benefit the whole community.

Mali OpenGL support on Allwinner platforms with mainline Linux

As most people know, getting GPU-based 3D acceleration to work on ARM platforms has always been difficult, due to the closed nature of the support for such GPUs. Most vendors provide closed-source binary-only OpenGL implementations in the form of binary blobs, whose quality depend on the vendor.

This situation is getting better and better through vendor-funded initiatives like for the Broadcom VC4 and VC5, or through reverse engineering projects like Nouveau on Tegra SoCs, Etnaviv on Vivante GPUs, Freedreno on Qualcomm’s. However there are still GPUs where you do not have the option to use a free software stack: PowerVR from Imagination Technologies and Mali from ARM (even though there is some progress on the reverse engineering effort).

Allwinner SoCs are using either a Mali GPU from ARM or a PowerVR from Imagination Technologies, and therefore, support for OpenGL on those platforms using a mainline Linux kernel has always been a problem. This is also further complicated by the fact that Allwinner is mostly interested in Android, which uses a different C library that avoids its use in traditional glibc-based systems (or through the use of libhybris).

However, we are happy to announce that Allwinner gave us clearance to publish the userspace binary blobs that allows to get OpenGL supported on Allwinner platforms that use a Mali GPU from ARM, using a recent mainline Linux kernel. Of course, those are closed source binary blobs and not a nice fully open-source solution, but it nonetheless allows everyone to have OpenGL support working, while taking advantage of all the benefits of a recent mainline Linux kernel. We have successfully used those binary blobs on customer projects involving the Allwinner A33 SoCs, and they should work on all Allwinner SoCs using the Mali GPU.

In order to get GPU support to work on your Allwinner platform, you will need:

  • The kernel-side driver, available on Maxime Ripard’s Github repository. This is essentially the Mali kernel-side driver from ARM, plus a number of build and bug fixes to make it work with recent mainline Linux kernels.
  • The Device Tree description of the GPU. We introduced Device Tree bindings for Mali GPUs in the mainline kernel a while ago, so that Device Trees can describe such GPUs. Such description has been added for the Allwinner A23 and A33 SoCs as part of this commit.
  • The userspace blob, which is available on Bootlin GitHub repository. It currently provides the r6p2 version of the driver, with support for both fbdev and X11 systems. Hopefully, we’ll gain access to newer versions in the future, with additional features (such as GBM support).

If you want to use it in your system, the first step is to have the GPU definition in your device tree if it’s not already there. Then, you need to compile the kernel module:

git clone https://github.com/mripard/sunxi-mali.git
cd sunxi-mali
export CROSS_COMPILE=$TOOLCHAIN_PREFIX
export KDIR=$KERNEL_BUILD_DIR
export INSTALL_MOD_PATH=$TARGET_DIR
./build.sh -r r6p2 -b
./build.sh -r r6p2 -i

It should install the mali.ko Linux kernel module into the target filesystem.

Now, you can copy the OpenGL userspace blobs that match your setup, most likely the fbdev or X11-dma-buf variant. For example, for fbdev:

git clone https://github.com/bootlin/mali-blobs.git
cd mali-blobs
cp -a r6p2/fbdev/lib/lib_fb_dev/lib* $TARGET_DIR/usr/lib

You should be all set. Of course, you will have to link your OpenGL applications or libraries against those user-space blobs. You can check that everything works using OpenGL test programs such as es2_gears for example.